Pravozhil.com > Housing and communal services issues > Homeowners' associations > Voting of apartment building owners - vote counting
In accordance with the Housing Code of the Russian Federation (LC RF), the owners of an apartment building must organize general meetings to resolve issues relating to their properties, conduct voting and correctly count votes.
Decisions at such meetings are often of a very important nature and therefore must be made through a fair voting procedure.
Poor awareness of citizens in the legislation of the Russian Federation often provokes incorrect vote counting or makes this event completely impossible.
In order to help readers, today our resource offers material on how to properly conduct the procedure for counting votes and the meeting as a whole.
By a simple majority of votes from the owners participating in the meeting - everything else, for example:
subject | question |
Issues related to common property | ✓ on the improvement of the land plot on which the house is located and which belongs to the common property, including the placement, maintenance and operation of landscaping and landscaping elements on such a site (clause 2.1, part 2, article 44 + part 1, art. 46 of the Housing Code of the Russian Federation), ✓ on current repairs of common property in the house (clause 4.1, part 2, article 44 + part 1, article 46 of the Housing Code of the Russian Federation), ✓ on identifying a person authorized on behalf of the owners to submit an application for state cadastral registration and (or) state registration of rights to real estate objects that are part of the common property by force of law, applications for state cadastral registration of an apartment building in connection with a change in its characteristics as a result of reconstruction or during redevelopment of the premises located in it (clause 3.6, part 2 Article 44 + Part 1 of Article 46 of the Housing Code of the Russian Federation). |
Issues related to the choice and implementation of a control method | ✓ selection of a management method for apartment buildings (part 3 of article 161, clause 4 of part 2 of article 44 + part 1 of article 46 of the Housing Code of the Russian Federation), ✓ choice of a management organization (part 8.2 of article 162 + part 1 of art. 46 of the Housing Code of the Russian Federation), ✓ approval of the terms of the management agreement for an apartment building (Part 1 of Article 162 + Part 1 of Article 46 of the Housing Code of the Russian Federation). In this case, the agreement itself must be signed by the owners who have at least 50% of the votes of the total number of votes of the owners. In connection with the requirement of the Housing Code of the Russian Federation for the owners to sign the agreement with 50% of the votes, there is a point of view that a decision on such an issue should also be made not by a simple majority of those participating, but by more than half the votes throughout the entire house. ✓ refusal to execute the management agreement unilaterally (part 8.2 of article 162 + part 1 of article 46 of the Housing Code of the Russian Federation), ✓ on the reorganization of the HOA by converting it into a housing cooperative or housing cooperative (part 2 of article 140 + part 1 of art. 46 of the Housing Code of the Russian Federation), ✓ on the liquidation of the HOA if its members do not have more than 50% of the votes of all owners (Part 2, Article 141 + Part 1, Article 46 of the Housing Code of the Russian Federation). |
Questions about the MKD council | ✓ selection and re-election of the MKD council and its chairman, election of owner commissions (Parts 1, 6, 12 of Article 161 + Part 1 of Article 46 of the Housing Code of the Russian Federation), ✓ on establishing remuneration for members of the MKD Council, including the chairman (Part. 8.1 Article 161 + Part 1 Article 46 of the Housing Code of the Russian Federation) ✓ on the term of office of the MKD council (by default – 2 years) (Part 10 of Article 161 + Part 1 of Article 46 of the Housing Code of the Russian Federation), ✓ on the use of the information system in the activities of the council of MKD and its chairman, commissions of owners in the event of their election, as well as on the determination of persons who, on behalf of the owners, are authorized to ensure the activities of the council, chairman, commissions (part 13 of article 161 + part 1 of article 46 of the Housing Code of the Russian Federation ). |
Issues regarding holding general meetings | ✓ on financing expenses associated with convening and organizing a meeting by the management organization, the board of the HOA or cooperative in accordance with Part 6 of Art. 45 of the Housing Code (clause 3.5, part 2, article 44 + part 1, article 46 of the Housing Code of the Russian Federation), ✓ on the method of sending to the owners a message about holding a general meeting or on a location accessible to all owners for posting such messages (part 4, art. 45 + part 1 of article 46 of the RF Housing Code), ✓ on the timing of the annual general meeting (part 1 of article 45 + part 1 of article 46 of the RF LC), ✓ on the place (address) of storing copies of minutes of meetings and decisions of owners (Part 4 of Article 46 + Part 1 of Article 46 of the Housing Code of the Russian Federation), ✓ on the premises accessible to all owners, in which the initiator posts the results of the meeting (Part 1 and Part 3 of Article 46 of the Housing Code of the Russian Federation), ✓ on using the information system when holding a general meeting of owners in the form of absentee voting (clause 3.2, part 2, article 44 + part 1, article 46 of the Housing Code of the Russian Federation), ✓ making decisions on identifying persons who, on behalf of the owners of premises in an apartment building, are authorized to use of the system or other information systems when holding a general meeting of owners of premises in an apartment building in the form of absentee voting (hereinafter referred to as the administrator of the general meeting) (clause. 3.3 hours 2 tbsp. 44 + part 1 tbsp. 46 of the Housing Code of the Russian Federation), ✓ deciding on the procedure for the administrator of the general meeting to receive messages about holding general meetings of owners of premises in an apartment building, decisions of owners of premises in an apartment building on issues put to vote, as well as on the duration of voting on issues on the agenda of the general meeting of owners premises in an apartment building in the form of absentee voting using the system (clause 3.4, part 2, article 44 + part 1, article 46 of the Housing Code of the Russian Federation) |
On the transition to direct contracts | ✓ on the conclusion by owners, acting on their own behalf, of agreements containing provisions for the provision of utility services, an agreement for the provision of services for the management of MSW with resource supply organizations and the regional operator for the management of MSW (Clause 4.4, Part 2, Article 44 + Part. 1, Article 46 of the Housing Code of the Russian Federation), ✓ on the date of concluding agreements containing provisions on the provision of utility services, contracts for the provision of services for the management of MSW with resource supply organizations and the regional operator for the management of MSW (Clause 1, Part 7, Article 157.2 + Part 1 of Article 46 of the Housing Code of the Russian Federation). |
About payment | ✓ on determining the amount of expenses for payment of utility resources consumed during the use and maintenance of common property based on the average monthly volume of their consumption, with recalculation based on the indications of the ODPU or based on the volume of consumption determined by the ODPU (Part 9. Article 156 + Part. 1, Article 46 of the Housing Code of the Russian Federation). |
Resolving issues related to direct house management | ✓ on the conclusion of contracts for the provision of services (performance of work) for the maintenance and repair of common property in a house with direct management (part 1 of article 164 + part 1 of article 46 of the Housing Code of the Russian Federation), ✓ on a person authorized to act in relations with third parties on behalf of the owners in a house with direct management (part 3 of article 164 + part 1 of article 46 of the Housing Code of the Russian Federation) |
All other issues within the competence of the general meeting of owners (clause 5, part 2, article 44 of the Housing Code), for example: | ✓ on refusal to indicate barcodes in the payment document when managing a house of an HOA or cooperative (subclause k(1) clause 69 of the Rules for the provision of public utilities No. 354 + part 1 of article 46 of the Housing Code of the Russian Federation), ✓ on addition to the list of “other documents” related to management, not specified in clause 26 of the Rules for the maintenance of common property No. 491 (subparagraph “e” of clause 26 of the Rules for the maintenance of common property No. 491+ part 1 of article 46 of the Housing Code of the Russian Federation) ✓ on the conclusion of an energy service agreement (contract) (clause 38(2) of the Rules for the maintenance of common property No. 491 + part 1 of article 46 of the Housing Code of the Russian Federation). |
Some wording in the law is not directly indicated, so the initiator has questions about where to include them, because the number of votes will depend on this: Is the barrier an improvement or about the limits of use of the land? Is a partition in common areas just a redevelopment or a reduction in common property? Is sealing a garbage chute some kind of reconstruction or reduction of common property, or is it simply a choice of waste collection method? Is installing video surveillance the use of common property, refurbishment or none of the above?
Initiators should focus on local judicial practice, or they can ask the housing inspector in advance.
Regulations for the procedure
The procedure for holding a meeting and referendum must be organized. Votes are counted at the general meeting of homeowners after the event is completed. Most often this happens behind closed doors by selected persons - the initiative group, the House Council, a representative of the Management Committee. They bear full responsibility for the transparency of the process.
Main nuances of the procedure:
- The form of voting can be in person, in absentia or in absentia.
- A quorum must be maintained.
- Mandatory protocol keeping.
- The result is recorded in the registry. The calculation specifies how many people participated in the process and their data:
- FULL NAME.;
- apartment number and square footage;
- contact details.
- The person initiating the meeting is obliged to notify all property owners. This event must be carried out no later than ten days in advance.
Note: compliance with formalities gives the meeting legitimacy, which is documented.
Requirements for registration of voting results of an apartment building by homeowners
Counting does not require any special skills, but everything should be done transparently so that you don’t need to check the results again later.
Principles and requirements:
- Drawing up a register and protocol. The documents specify the definition of quorum and the composition of the counting commission.
- Ballots and sheets are checked and counted manually. During this process, observers must be present. Controversial issues require additional verification.
- Availability of powers of attorney from persons who are representatives of the owners.
Please note: all accompanying documents must be prepared strictly according to the templates.
Voting sheet
The progress of any meeting must be shown in writing. The percentage of votes of the owners is needed to make a decision after counting. Summarizing is done on sheets. The design of the form is influenced by the resident's status.
The individual indicates:
- FULL NAME.;
- apartment number and square footage;
- passport data.
The organization is obliged to provide the ORGN and TIN of the company.
If any data is missing from the sheet, this is considered a violation.
What information should be included in residents' voting protocols?
Each protocol must contain the required details:
- Document's name.
- Date and number.
- The essence of the meeting or vote.
- Signatures of responsible persons.
- The place where the documentation will be stored.
Note: all participants in the process must sign the protocol.
Shared ownership and co-ownership
In accordance with Articles 245-252 of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation, currently in force with amendments, common private, privatized property can be shared or, referring to Articles 253-259 of the same code, joint. As a rule, no difficulties arise with shared ownership, since the share is specifically allocated, as evidenced by the relevant documents. To determine the percentage of votes here, you need to multiply the area of your share by 100 and divide by the total area of the house, just as is done in ordinary cases. When calculating the quorum at a meeting, only those numbers and citizens that are recorded in the documents are taken into account.
An example of how a vote in shared ownership is counted |
The apartment, with an area of 68 square meters, belongs to two shareholders, where one owns one-fourth, and the second – three-quarters. Provided that the area of the apartment building is 6035 square meters, then: the first shareholder has - (68/4)*100/6035=0.28 votes the second shareholder has - (68/4*3)*100/6035=0.84 votes. |
The first and second parts of Article 253 of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation establish that the owners of premises in joint ownership use real estate and dispose of it on an equal basis, since the shares are not allocated. Thus, any co-owner can be present at the meeting, and the percentage of votes will be determined per apartment, and not on individual co-owners, no matter how many housing units are registered.
Number of votes to make a decision
Each resident has a voice. Units (percentage) are equal to the footage of the property. Let's consider an example: a person owns an apartment of 50 m2, and according to the register, the total area of the apartment building is 4000 meters, respectively, out of 4000, 50 are in his competence.
Note: you can count votes at a general meeting of owners using an example, taking into account the proposed formula.
How to hold a homeowners meeting
A third of all votes is sufficient to make a decision. Using a calculator, you can find out that in this situation the number is 1739.
The calculation is made using the formula: divide the total area of the apartment building by 2/3.
That is, at least 35 apartments with this footage must be voted on.
The concept of quorum
Quorum means the number or percentage required for a meeting or session to take place. The number of voting persons should not be less than 2/3 of the total number. To determine the quorum, you need to make a simple calculation.
Example: if the apartment is 43 m2, and the area of the house is 5000, then: 43/5000*100=0.86% (the percentage taken into account in the referendum for this tenant).
Note: in order to vote and then sum up the results, the statement must be certified by all representatives of the counting commission of the housing cooperative in accordance with the provisions reflected in the Charter of the MKD.
Calculator for counting votes at a meeting of apartment building residents
Real estate can be not only an apartment, but also utility rooms. The owners of such areas also have the right to vote. To make the calculations correctly, you can use a calculator.
Often it is created in Excel format yourself or using a tool on the Internet. To do this, you need to type “meeting voting calculator” into the search bar. The World Wide Web will provide several links upon request, from which the desired option is selected. Then, the user needs to set the organization parameters and maintain information.
Can a tenant of an apartment building check the voting protocol and how to do it
Documents are often falsified by interested parties, so the protocol is checked, if there are prerequisites for voting to be carried out with violations. It is necessary to form an independent commission from the management company or from the owners.
Additionally, you can contact the State Housing Inspectorate for an inspection.
OSS forms for MKD premises